What Kind of Olive Oil Should You Use in an Olive Oil Cake?

We love oil-based truffles. Like to bake them, like to eat them, like to share them. They’re the ticket to stress-free, reliably moist, and tremendous tender desserts, they usually normally may be made with out having to cream butter and sugar collectively. (Such a problem!) Usually, they’re as easy to assemble as stirring collectively your moist and dry elements and popping into the oven.

And in terms of oil-based truffles, olive oil cakes will all the time have a particular place in our hearts. They’ve bought the whole lot we love about this no-fuss fashion of cake with the added bonus of the fruity, grassy flavors that come from good high quality extra-virgin olive oil. Usually, citrus akin to orange zest or lemon zest is added to intensify the fruitier notes of the oil used. They’re normally a little bit denser than your common birthday cake, and have a young crumb that can keep moist even after sitting in your countertop for a pair days, making them excellent for gifting. However all this olive oil cake speak begs one crucial query: What sort of olive oil must you use for baking, anyway?

The brief reply: nothing too expensive, nothing too low-cost, however someplace within the center, Goldilocks-style. You positively need an olive oil with “extra-virgin” on the label, however you don’t should shell out for fancy-shmancy single-estate stuff. Whereas we’re enormous followers of complicated, fragrant olive oils that boast peppery, herby nuances (we love those made by Brightland), it will possibly get costly when recipes name for 1½ to 2 cups of olive oil for one cake. 

On the flip facet, cheaper, bulk grocery store manufacturers are sometimes very processed, and may be too impartial and bland to lend any actual taste. If there are any disagreeable flavors or smells you’re not a fan of within the oil, baking it right into a cake will solely put these flaws entrance and middle. Much like cooking with wine, the final rule of thumb must be to cook dinner with an olive oil you’d already attain for as a ending oil, whether or not to dunk bread in, drizzle over salads, or to top vanilla ice cream.

Mina Stone, creator of Lemon, Love & Olive Oil, recommends in her cookbook to take the additional time to discover a favourite, dependable model you get pleasure from cooking with—she’s keen on Greek origin olive oils.

“Good Greek olive tastes like heavy cream and has a clear end. It smells even and clear—with out the rancid undertones which might be widespread in blended and outdated olive oils,” she writes. “Center Jap and Greek grocery shops are an important place to purchase olive oil; they sometimes have massive tins of high-quality oil at a great value. In case you are at your native grocery retailer, attempt to discover extra-virgin olive oil that’s from one explicit area (not a mix).”

Time to get baking:

Super Lemony Olive Oil Cake

When life provides you lemons, make Mina Stone’s irresistibly moist and zesty olive oil cake. 

View Recipe